Science & Technology

What Robert Caro learned about power after studying it for 50 years

by Dwarkesh Patel

Share:

📚 Main topics

  • How Caro gets people to talkCaro pursues the people who can answer his questions, even when they resist, and uses documents and specific questions to draw out revealing details. 2:17
  • Moses and building public worksRobert Moses overcame obstacles to build roads and parks, but his early idealism hardened into ruthless determination that disregarded public opinion and displaced residents. 6:46
  • Power and its limitsMoses’s influence came from popularity and an interlocking network of public positions, while Lyndon Johnson’s persuasive personality was backed by real leverage over colleagues’ careers and legislation. 22:18
  • Johnson’s domestic legacy and VietnamCaro credits Johnson’s determination to help poor people with major domestic achievements, while describing Vietnam as the tragedy that derailed his presidency. 36:45
  • Biography and the research processCaro tries to define a book’s purpose in one sentence before writing, and stresses that finding documents is far quicker than carefully reading them. 41:41
  • The value of the archiveCaro donated his research to the New-York Historical Society so future scholars can study the interviews and material that could not fit into his books. 50:42
  • Loneliness and concentrationCaro protects long stretches of uninterrupted work, even though this means delaying calls and accepting a degree of isolation. 59:09

✨ Key takeaways

  • Power can make things happenMoses and Johnson achieved ambitious goals because they combined determination with the ability to overcome or wield institutional and political obstacles. 11:00
  • Power can harden its holderMoses’s growing ruthlessness shows how a commitment to getting things done can become indifference to the people harmed along the way. 25:38
  • Political skill depends on contextThe Depression gave Moses access to large numbers of skilled, unemployed workers, helping make his public works possible. 28:56
  • Historical records preserve what books omitCaro’s extensive notes and interviews contain information that never made it into his published work, but can still inform future histories. 49:04

🧠 Lessons learned

  • Define the book’s purpose earlyCaro recommends articulating a book’s central idea in a sentence or short paragraph, so the writing stays coherent over many years. 42:11
  • Look beyond famous individualsThe lives and circumstances of ordinary people and communities can reveal fascinating histories, including the isolation and hardship of frontier life. 53:31
  • Make room for sustained focusCaro’s practice of limiting interruptions helps him maintain concentration, though it can strain the expectations of friends and family. 59:40

📚 Conclusion/next steps

  • Keep the historical record accessibleCaro hopes scholars will use his archive to explore stories and context that he could not include in his books. 51:16
  • Continue the Vietnam researchCaro is working on a book about Vietnam and is still trying to understand why Johnson continued escalating the war. 38:59

Transcript excerpt

0:00 "If you do everything, you will win." That is the maxim by which Lyndon Johnson lived his life. My guest today is Robert Caro. Over the 50 years that he has spent writing  about Lyndon Johnson, he has lived in the edges of the Texas Hill Country to understand  the poverty and loneliness of Johnson’s youth. He has sifted through millions of documents  in the Senate and presidential libraries of the entire nation. He has chased down for interviews everyone, from the former goon who  helped Johnson steal an election to the chauffeur

0:32 who drove him on his first desperate campaign. In other words, my guest today is a man who understands Johnson’s aphorism:  "If you do everything, you’ll win." Mr. Caro, it is such a huge  honor to have you on the show. It’s great to be here. My first question is what I hinted at in the introduction. How much do you see yourself represented in Johnson or in Moses? Is part of the reason you’re able to write so compellingly about them that  you share some of their qualities?

1:06 Let me say first, I think, I hope, there are  qualities of both these guys that I don’t share. Among other things they’re so,  I’ll use the word, ruthless. You say they’d do anything to win. That’s part of their greatness. I remember when I started learning about  Robert Moses, I went to the LaGuardia papers, which were kept in the Boat Basin. They were stored by the Municipal Archives,

🔒 The full, searchable transcript is available with Pro.

🔒 Unlock Premium Features

This is a premium feature. Upgrade to unlock unlimited Q&A, transcripts, mindmaps, and translations.

Questions & Answers

Common questions about this video

What did Robert Caro learn about how Robert Moses overcame obstacles to build public works?

Moses found ways around seemingly insurmountable barriers, including property owners who opposed his projects. Caro saw his achievements as a combination of political genius and sheer willpower. 6:12

Did Caro think America needs another Robert Moses?

Caro said he would not want someone as ruthless or dismissive of public opinion as Moses, but agreed that the country needs people who can find ways to get important things built despite opposition. 11:35

How did Robert Moses change over the course of his career?

Caro described Moses as beginning as an idealist who wanted to reform civil service and make beaches accessible to ordinary New Yorkers. Over time, he became increasingly ruthless, focused on building what he wanted regardless of the harm or opposition involved. 13:56

What question would Robert Caro most want to ask Robert Moses?

Caro said he would ask Moses, “Did you realize you were changing?” Caro doubted that Moses recognized his own transformation, believing he saw his vision as right from the beginning. 24:01

What was the source of Lyndon Johnson’s persuasive power?

Caro said Johnson’s persuasion was backed by leverage. People knew Johnson could help or hinder them by granting favors, such as committee assignments, or influencing whether legislation passed. 32:51

How does Caro keep a long biography focused?

Before writing, Caro tries to define the entire book in a sentence or, at most, a paragraph. That central idea helps him keep the material connected and avoid losing track of what the book is about. 41:41

Why did Caro donate his archives to the New-York Historical Society?

Caro wanted his research and interviews to be accessible to future scholars in New York. He chose the society even though other institutions offered him more money, because he wanted researchers to be able to consult the material he could not include in his books. 50:42

How has working in isolation affected Caro’s life?

Caro said he turns off his telephone and avoids conversations during the workday to protect his concentration. He acknowledged that this limits contact with friends and has affected his life as a whole. 58:29

🔒 Unlock Premium Features

Access to Chat is a premium feature. Upgrade now to unlock unlimited studying tools.

🔒 Unlock Premium Features

Access to Mindmap is a premium feature. Upgrade now to unlock unlimited studying tools.

🔒 Unlock Premium Features

Access to Translation is a premium feature. Upgrade now to unlock unlimited studying tools.

Get unlimited summaries, Q&A, transcripts and more with Pro

Upgrade to Pro

Suggestions

🔒 Unlock Premium Features

Access to AI Suggestions is a premium feature. Upgrade now to unlock unlimited studying tools.